1. Did Oberyn poison Tywin?: The Case Against

    In the latest Podcast of Ice and Fire, Elio and Linda and the hosts have a laugh at the expense of various “Tywin Lannister was poisoned” theories, including mine own contention that the Red Viper had slipped him some Widow’s Blood. As an ASoIaF fan, you haven’t known heartache until a chuckling Elio Garcia refers to your pet theory as “total nonsense,” let me just tell you. Anyway, Linda does the bulk of the debunking, asserting that there’s nothing about either death or even getting shot in the bowels that would magically undo the work of a poison that completely shuts down the excretory system — since Tywin does shit as he dies, we can therefore deduce that the fatal constipation induced by Widow’s Blood wasn’t in effect. I confess I have no idea how such a thing would work, and that my assumption had always been that a crossbow quarrel in your guttyworks is the ultimate laxative, but I could certainly be wrong about that.

    But this got me to thinking of another, more definitive way to debunk my theory: listening to what Prince Doran has to say about his brother, and about his plans for vengeance.

    Here he is talking to Ellaria in “The Princess in the Tower” from Feast:

    “You mistake patience for forbearance. I have worked at the downfall of Tywin Lannister since the day they told me of Elia and her children. It was my hope to strip him of all that he held most dear before I killed him, but it would seem his dwarf son has robbed me of that pleasure.”

    And here he is talking to the Sand Snakes in Areo’s chapter from Dance, “The Watcher”:

    “I am not blind, nor deaf. I know that you all believe me weak, frightened, feeble. Your father knew me better. Oberyn was ever the viper. Deadly, dangerous, unpredictable. No man dared tread on him. I was the grass. Pleasant, complaisant, sweet-smelling, swaying with every breeze. Who fears to walk upon the grass? But it is the grass that hides the viper from his enemies and shelters him until he strikes. Your father and I worked more closely than you know …”

    Put the two together, and it seems unlikely that Oberyn, who’d apparently worked hand in hand with Doran for years on the secret plot, would suddenly seek to ice Tywin before allowing him to witness the utter ruin of House Lannister, as was Doran’s intent.

     
  1. spikelvr75 likes this
  2. gabisalamoni likes this
  3. fantasticpinkcoat likes this
  4. kiradax likes this
  5. nhyorange likes this
  6. nothingiseverautomatic reblogged this from boiledleather
  7. nothingiseverautomatic likes this
  8. dalekofchaos likes this
  9. hisladylyanna likes this
  10. queenkobara likes this
  11. staarked likes this
  12. becauseforoncethisisme likes this
  13. ladyfabulous likes this
  14. motivatedslacker likes this
  15. ladyoflate likes this
  16. blav527 likes this
  17. johncipollina likes this
  18. spanghew likes this
  19. hummingbird-knowledge likes this
  20. racefortheironthrone likes this
  21. wereallpeoplehere likes this
  22. dk65 reblogged this from asoiafuniversity and added:
    So just how did Doran and Oberyn plan to hit back at Tywin? One was of course the plan to wed Arianne to Viserys and...
  23. dk65 likes this
  24. asoiafuniversity reblogged this from boiledleather
  25. stupidstubbornbravebitch likes this
  26. driftingskylark likes this
  27. asexualdaryldixon likes this
  28. eastwatch likes this
  29. queenswrath likes this
  30. ghostsinwinterfell reblogged this from fearbreeze
  31. lorsasstyrell likes this
  32. fearbreeze reblogged this from joannalannister
  33. fearbreeze likes this
  34. joannalannister reblogged this from boiledleather
  35. hagbardceline reblogged this from boiledleather and added:
    debate aside (i believe tywin WAS poisoned by oberyn) it’s really just reminding...Oberyn...
  36. boiledleather posted this